Plagiarism and Retraction

Plagiarism and Retraction Policy

Originality standards, similarity screening, sanctions, and corrections in the International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Intelligent Computing (IJEEIC)

1. Definition and Principles

Plagiarism is the use or close imitation of another author's language and ideas, presented as one's own original work. IJEEIC does not tolerate plagiarism in any form.

  • Submitted papers must be original, unpublished, and not under consideration by any other journal.
  • Text copied from another source must be clearly marked with quotation marks or indentation and cited properly.
  • Copying more than two or three sentences beyond fair use, or reproducing figures and tables, requires permission from the copyright holder and a clear citation of the source.
  • All authors share responsibility for the content of a manuscript; any sanction applies equally to every author.

↑ Back to Top

2. Similarity Screening

Screening tool
Turnitin
Maximum similarity
25%
Checked at
Submission & final version

Every manuscript is checked with Turnitin when it is submitted and again when its final version is ready for publication. Manuscripts with a similarity index above 25% are returned to the authors for correction and resubmission. When plagiarism is found, the Editor-in-Chief responsible for the paper decides on the action according to the level of plagiarism.

↑ Back to Top

3. Levels of Plagiarism and Sanctions

Level Description Sanction
Minor A short section of another article is copied without taking significant data or ideas. Warning, with a request to revise the text and cite the original source properly.
Intermediate A significant portion of a paper is copied without proper citation. Rejection; the authors may not submit to IJEEIC for 1 year.
Severe A significant portion of a paper is copied and reproduces original results or ideas from another publication. Rejection; the authors may not submit to IJEEIC for 5 years.
Repeated cases A second case of plagiarism by the same author(s). Decided by the Editorial Board; the authors may be permanently barred from submitting.

The layout editor keeps a record of sanctioned authors and checks new submissions against it. Submissions from barred authors are reported to the Editor-in-Chief.

↑ Back to Top

4. Self-Plagiarism and Overlapping Publication

Material reused from the authors' own earlier publications must be clearly identified and cited. Review papers and tutorials may naturally contain previously published material, but it must still be referenced.

Extent of overlap Classification
≥ 50% of the paper Severe — identical or near-identical figures and text submitted simultaneously to another journal. The editor of the other journal will be informed.
10% – 50% of the paper Intermediate self-plagiarism.
Methods section only Minor self-plagiarism.

↑ Back to Top

5. Conference Papers, Translations, and Republication

  • Conference papers: an extended version may be submitted if the proceedings and publication date are stated and copyright permission has been obtained. The editor may still decline the paper.
  • Unpublished presentations: material from talks or posters that were not formally published, including visual displays, may be used in a later journal article.
  • Translations: the original title, date, and journal must be identified and copyright permission obtained. The editor may accept a translation to reach a wider readership.
  • Historic papers: republication is allowed only when clearly labeled as such, with the original date, journal, and permissions stated.

↑ Back to Top

6. Retraction and Corrections

Withdrawal by Authors

Authors are strongly discouraged from withdrawing a manuscript once it has entered the publication process. A withdrawal request must be emailed to the editor from the same email address used in correspondence with the journal.

Grounds for Retraction

An article may be retracted when:

  • there is clear evidence that the findings are unreliable, because of honest error, data fabrication, or falsification;
  • it constitutes plagiarism or redundant publication;
  • it uses material or data without authorization, or raises copyright or other legal problems;
  • it reports unethical research;
  • the peer review process was compromised or manipulated; or
  • the authors failed to disclose a major competing interest that would have affected the editors' or reviewers' judgment.

Retraction Notices

A retraction notice is published promptly, is freely accessible, is clearly labeled and linked to the retracted article, identifies the article by title and authors, and states objectively who is retracting it and why.

Other Corrective Actions

Action When it applies
Correction A small part of an otherwise reliable article proves to be misleading, usually because of honest error, or the author list is incorrect.
Expression of Concern Evidence of misconduct is inconclusive, findings may be unreliable but the institution has not investigated, an investigation was not fair or conclusive, or an investigation is ongoing but will take time.
No retraction Authorship is disputed but the findings are sound, errors can be fixed by a correction, evidence is inconclusive, or a late-disclosed conflict of interest is unlikely to have affected the work.

All retractions and corrections follow the COPE Retraction Guidelines and the journal's Publication Ethics policy.

↑ Back to Top

This policy is published on the journal website and sent to authors with the submission acknowledgement. Questions: ijeeic.unkhair@gmail.com