Publication Ethics
Publication Ethics
Ethical standards and responsibilities for authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher of International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Intelligent Computing (IJEEIC)
The International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Intelligent Computing (IJEEIC) is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal published by the Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Khairun. The journal publishes original research in electrical and electronic engineering, power and energy systems, control and instrumentation, telecommunications, embedded systems, artificial intelligence, machine learning, and intelligent computing. IJEEIC is committed to integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability at every stage of the editorial and publication process.
IJEEIC follows the Core Practices and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). All parties involved in publishing with the journal — authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher — are expected to apply these principles and to help prevent research and publication misconduct.
Contents
|
1. Ethical Responsibilities of Authors
2. Ethical Responsibilities of Editors
3. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers
|
4. Responsibilities of the Publisher
5. Research and Publication Misconduct
6. Handling Allegations of Misconduct
7. Corrections, Expressions of Concern and Retractions
|
8. Post-Publication Discussion
9. Reporting Ethical Concerns
10. COPE Guidelines and Best Practices
11. Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies
|
2. Ethical Responsibilities of Editors
- Editorial Independence: Editors decide on manuscripts independently, based on originality, technical soundness, significance, clarity, and fit with the journal's aims and scope. Decisions are not influenced by the publisher, funders, advertisers, or commercial interests.
- Fairness and Non-Discrimination: Manuscripts are judged on scholarly merit alone, without regard to the authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, political views, institution, or seniority.
- Confidentiality: Editors share information about a submitted manuscript only with the authors, reviewers, editorial staff, and the publisher as needed for the editorial process. Unpublished material must not be used in an editor's own research without the authors' written consent.
- Conflict of Interest: Editors must step aside from any manuscript where they have a financial, institutional, collaborative, or personal conflict. Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial board are handled by another editor and go through the same peer-review process as all other submissions.
- Peer Review Integrity: Editors ensure that each manuscript sent for review is evaluated by at least two qualified, independent reviewers with relevant expertise and no significant conflict of interest.
- Editorial Decision-Making: Decisions to accept, revise, or reject are based on the manuscript's merits, reviewers' reports, and the journal's policies. IJEEIC does not offer paid or guaranteed fast-track acceptance, and no Letter of Acceptance is issued before formal acceptance.
- Handling Misconduct: Editors act on credible evidence or allegations of plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, duplicate publication, authorship problems, citation or peer-review manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other misconduct, following Section 6.
- Corrections and Retractions: Editors publish corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions whenever reliable evidence shows that the published record needs to be amended (see Section 7).
- Protection of the Scholarly Record: Editors take all reasonable steps to keep the journal's published record accurate, complete, and trustworthy.
3. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers
- Contribution to Editorial Decisions: Reviewers help editors judge the originality, technical correctness, significance, and clarity of a manuscript, and their comments help authors improve their work.
- Expertise and Timeliness: A reviewer who lacks the expertise to assess a manuscript, or cannot finish the review within the requested time, should tell the editorial office promptly so another reviewer can be invited.
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers must not share, discuss, copy, or use any unpublished content, data, code, or designs, and must not upload any part of a manuscript to an AI tool (see Section 11).
- Objectivity: Reviews should be professional, specific, and constructive. Comments must address the work, not the authors, and each judgment should be supported by reasons.
- Technical Verification: Where possible, reviewers should check whether the methods, equations, simulations, experiments, and statistical analyses support the conclusions, and whether enough detail is given for the results to be reproduced.
- Acknowledgment of Sources: Reviewers should point out relevant published work that the authors have missed. Reviewers must not ask authors to cite the reviewer's own work, or any journal, unless the reference is genuinely needed.
- Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must disclose any competing, collaborative, institutional, financial, or personal relationship with the authors or the subject of the manuscript, and decline the review where the conflict is significant.
- Reporting Concerns: Reviewers should inform the editor of suspected plagiarism, substantial overlap with other publications, fabricated or manipulated data or images, ethical problems, citation manipulation, or other possible misconduct.
4. Responsibilities of the Publisher
The Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Khairun, as publisher of IJEEIC, supports the editorial independence of the journal and is committed to high standards of research integrity, publication ethics, transparency, and quality.
The publisher works with the editorial team to prevent and address misconduct and supports corrective measures such as corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions whenever they are needed to protect the scholarly record. The publisher maintains a documented procedure for handling allegations (Sections 6 and 7), ensures the long-term preservation of published content (for example, through digital archiving services and DOI registration), and supports ongoing training of editors and reviewers in publication ethics.
5. Research and Publication Misconduct
IJEEIC has zero tolerance for practices that undermine the integrity of research and publishing. Misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
- Plagiarism: Using another person's text, ideas, figures, data, algorithms, or code without proper attribution; rewriting another's work too closely even when cited; and reusing one's own published text or results without citation (self-plagiarism). All submissions are screened with similarity-checking software. A similarity score alone does not prove plagiarism; editors judge whether significant overlap is present and not properly quoted or cited.
- Fabrication and Falsification: Inventing, altering, or misrepresenting data, measurements, simulation outputs, images, circuit layouts, or results, including manipulating figures or plots.
- Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Publishing substantially the same work in more than one venue without disclosure, including undisclosed overlap with conference papers or theses.
- Concurrent Submission: Submitting the same or a substantially similar manuscript to more than one journal or conference at the same time.
- Paper Mills and Fake Submissions: Submitting manuscripts produced by commercial "paper mills", or containing fabricated content, tortured phrases, or machine-generated text presented as original research.
- Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest: Failing to disclose interests that could reasonably influence the work or the review.
- Citation Manipulation: Excessive self-citation, citation cartels, or coercive or irrelevant citation requests intended to inflate citation metrics.
- Peer-Review Manipulation: Suggesting fake reviewers, reviewing one's own work, or otherwise interfering with the independence of peer review.
- Misrepresentation of Data, Code, or Benchmarks: Reporting results that cannot be produced with the described method, testing on training data, hiding unfavourable results, or misrepresenting the performance of competing methods.
- Manipulation of Metadata or Publication Dates: Altering article metadata, submission history, or publication dates, or inserting articles into issues already published.
- Breach of Confidentiality: Unauthorized disclosure or use of confidential manuscripts, review reports, data, or personal information.
- Misuse of Artificial Intelligence: Undisclosed or inappropriate use of generative AI that compromises authorship, originality, accuracy, or confidentiality (see Section 11).
- Other Unethical Practices: Any other conduct that compromises the integrity, transparency, or reliability of research and publication.
6. Handling Allegations of Misconduct
Allegations of misconduct are handled fairly, confidentially, and in line with the journal's policies and the relevant COPE flowcharts.
- Initial Assessment: The editorial office reviews the allegation and the available evidence to decide whether further investigation is warranted.
- Request for Explanation: The author, reviewer, editor, or other party concerned is contacted and given a fair opportunity to respond and provide supporting information.
- Further Investigation: Where needed, the journal may request original data, code, or lab records, seek independent expert opinion, or contact the authors' institution or funder.
- Evaluation and Decision: The Editor-in-Chief decides on the matter based on the evidence, the journal's policies, and accepted ethical standards.
- Corrective Action: Depending on seriousness, actions may include rejection or withdrawal of the manuscript, correction, expression of concern, retraction, a ban on future submissions for a set period, or notification of the authors' institutions or funders (see Section 7).
Confidentiality is maintained throughout, and all parties are given a fair chance to respond. Every step is documented and records are kept by the editorial office.
7. Corrections, Expressions of Concern and Retractions
Principle: A published article (the version of record) is never changed or removed silently; every change is announced in a public notice. IJEEIC follows the COPE Retraction Guidelines.
Authority: The Editor-in-Chief decides on corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and withdrawals, after an assessment under Section 6 and, where appropriate, consultation with the Editorial Board. Editors with a conflict of interest in the case do not take part. Authors are always given a chance to respond before a decision, and the publisher is informed of every retraction.
Types of Corrective Action
- Correction: For an error that does not change the main results or conclusions. An erratum fixes an error introduced during production; a corrigendum fixes an error made by the authors.
- Expression of Concern: Issued when there are serious doubts about an article and an investigation is ongoing or inconclusive. It is updated or replaced once the matter is resolved.
- Retraction: Issued when reliable evidence shows the findings can no longer be trusted, for example because of fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, unauthorized authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, unethical research, or a major honest error (such as a coding or calculation mistake that invalidates the results).
- Withdrawal: Applies to an accepted manuscript or Article in Press that has not yet been published as the final version of record. The withdrawn article is replaced by a notice explaining the reason.
Procedure
- A concern or request reaches the editorial office (see Sections 8 and 9) or is raised by the editors.
- The Editor-in-Chief makes an initial assessment within 14 working days.
- The corresponding author is asked to explain and provide evidence within 30 days.
- If needed, the journal investigates further and may contact the authors' institution, funders, or other parties.
- The Editor-in-Chief decides on the action and informs the authors of the decision and its reasons.
- The notice is published and the article record updated. All steps are documented by the editorial office.
Notices
Each notice is openly accessible and titled "Correction to:", "Expression of Concern:", or "Retraction Note:" followed by the article title. It identifies the article, the type of action, the reason, and who issued it. The notice and the original article are linked to each other, and DOI metadata (Crossref) and indexing records are updated.
Retracted Articles
Retracted articles remain on the journal website. The article page is labelled "RETRACTED" and linked to the Retraction Note, each page of the PDF carries a "RETRACTED" watermark, and metadata is updated. Content is removed only where legally required (for example, a court order or a serious risk to privacy or safety); the bibliographic record and an explanatory notice then remain online.
Errors Reported by Authors
Authors who find a significant error in their published article must notify the editorial office promptly and cooperate in correcting or retracting it. Prompt, transparent self-correction is taken into account when deciding on the appropriate action.
8. Post-Publication Discussion
IJEEIC welcomes scholarly discussion of published articles. Readers and researchers may raise substantive questions about an article's accuracy, reproducibility, originality, authorship, or ethics.
How to Take Part
- Comments and Replies: Readers may submit a Comment on an article within 12 months of its publication by writing to [editorial email]. Comments should not exceed 1,500 words, must address the technical content, and must be properly referenced. Editors assess each Comment and may send it for peer review. The original authors are invited to submit a Reply, and accepted Comments and Replies are published together and linked to the article.
- Concerns about Errors or Integrity: Anyone who believes an article contains a significant error or raises an ethical issue should contact the editorial office (see Section 9). Such concerns are handled under Sections 6 and 7.
- External Platforms: The journal monitors substantive concerns about its articles raised on public post-publication review platforms and responds where concerns are specific and supported by evidence.
Standards of Discussion: Contributions must be courteous, focus on arguments and evidence rather than individuals, and disclose any conflict of interest. Comments are published under the writer's name; integrity concerns may be raised confidentially if supported by specific information.
Outcome: Post-publication discussion may lead to a published Comment and Reply, a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction (see Section 7).
9. Reporting Ethical Concerns
How to Report: Authors, reviewers, readers, and others who suspect research or publication misconduct involving IJEEIC should contact the editorial office at [editorial email]. Reports should include enough detail and, where possible, supporting evidence (for example, links to overlapping publications, figures, or datasets) to allow a fair assessment.
Confidentiality and Fairness: All reports are handled responsibly and confidentially. The journal avoids premature conclusions and ensures a fair process for everyone involved. The identity of the person reporting is protected where requested.
10. COPE Guidelines and Best Practices
IJEEIC applies recognized principles of publication ethics and editorial integrity. For ethical issues not covered in this policy, the editors refer to the guidelines, flowcharts, Core Practices, and discussion documents of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
COPE guidance is used for matters such as authorship disputes, conflicts of interest, peer-review problems, plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or falsification, paper mills, corrections, and retractions. The journal also follows the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
11. Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies
Scope
This policy covers the use of generative AI and AI-assisted tools by authors, editors, and reviewers in writing, editing, and peer review. It follows the COPE position statement on Authorship and AI Tools. Because IJEEIC publishes research on artificial intelligence, the policy distinguishes between AI used as a research method or subject and AI used to prepare the manuscript.
AI as Part of the Research
AI models, tools, or code generators used as part of the research itself (for example, models being proposed, trained, or evaluated, or AI used to generate data, designs, or code for experiments) must be fully described in the Methods section, including the tool, version, configuration, and how outputs were validated. This use is not restricted by this policy beyond the normal requirements for reproducibility and transparency.
Authors' Use of AI in Manuscript Preparation
- Authors may use generative AI only to improve language, readability, and presentation. It must not replace the authors' own scientific work: formulating research questions, designing methods, analysing results, interpreting findings, or drawing conclusions.
- AI must never be used to create, alter, or summarize data, measurements, results, references, or quotations. AI-generated images, figures, or tables are not accepted unless AI is the subject of the research and its use is described in the Methods.
- All AI use must be under the authors' direct supervision, with human review and editing. AI outputs can look convincing while being wrong, biased, or invented, including non-existent references. Authors must check every citation against its original source and remain fully responsible for all content.
- Disclosure is mandatory for every manuscript. Each manuscript must include a Generative AI Declaration placed after the Conflict of Interest Statement and before the Acknowledgments. Where AI was used, it must name each tool and version, its purpose, and the sections concerned. Where no AI was used, it must state so, for example: "The authors declare that no generative AI or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation of this manuscript." Built-in spelling and grammar checkers need not be declared.
- AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors, because authorship requires accountability and approval of the final work.
Editors' Use of AI
- Editors must not upload submitted manuscripts, any part of them, review reports, or personal data of authors and reviewers to generative AI platforms or external AI systems.
- Editors may use AI only in a supporting role: improving the language of editorial correspondence, searching literature without disclosing manuscript content, and using screening tools provided through the journal's editorial system under confidentiality terms (for example, similarity checking). Approved tools may support technical checks such as formatting and reference completeness, provided confidentiality is protected.
- AI must not be used to assess a manuscript's merit, recommend a decision, or make a decision. Every editorial decision is made, and owned, by a human editor.
- An editor who uses an AI tool while handling a manuscript must record the tool and purpose in the manuscript file in the editorial system, where the Editor-in-Chief can review it.
Use of AI in Peer Review
- Reviewers must not use generative AI or AI-assisted tools at any stage of the review, including to read, evaluate, summarize, or interpret a manuscript, or to draft, translate, or polish review comments.
- Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, excerpts, unpublished data, code, designs, or supplementary materials to AI platforms, as this may breach confidentiality, intellectual property, and data protection.
- Reviewers remain personally responsible for the content and quality of their reports. By submitting a report, reviewers confirm that no AI tool was used. Reports that appear AI-generated may be disregarded, and the reviewer may be removed from the reviewer pool.
Breaches of this Policy
Undisclosed or prohibited use of AI is handled under Section 6. Depending on its seriousness, it may lead to rejection, correction, an expression of concern, or retraction (see Section 7).
Policy Review
IJEEIC will review this policy at least once a year, and whenever COPE guidance changes, to keep pace with developments in generative AI and to maintain high standards of integrity, transparency, confidentiality, and publication ethics.

